Are these extreme measures really necessary?

According to PTI reports,  the Assam (a North-Eastern state in India) government  is exploring  whether trimming of horns would  save rhinos from poaching! Last month, Assam Forest and Environment minister  Rockybul Hussain had said the government will set up a committee to study if the horn of a rhino could be trimmed without any harm to the animal to save it from poaching.

Immediately the environmentalists objected to this. According to them -  trimming of horns will affect biological growth of the animal and the risk from poachers will continue. "The horn of a rhino is a part of its biological growth. With the help of the horn, the animal selects a mate for breeding. So removing the horn will be detrimental to the rhino population," Nature's Beckon Director Soumyadeep Datta explained. He said a study by environmentalist Janet Rachlow revealed that 90 per cent of the dehorned white rhinos were poached within 18 months as the horns grow back very quickly.
If the horn is cut too close to the germinal layer, this could damage the horn base and lead to deformed horn re-growth or death of the individual rhino due to blood loss or shock, he said and cited the instance of a rhino death at Majuli after its horn was surgically removed by forest authorities in March 2013. Nature's Beckon also opposed to translocation of rhinos saying it was against nature. "So far eight rhinos have been killed in Manas National Park by poachers. Before we translocate rhinos, the security aspect should have been checked properly," he said.

According to the NGO's estimates, about 12 rhinos have been translocated to Manas from Kaziranga National Park in the last three years. Coupled with natural breeding the rhino population at Manas had increased to over 20, of which eight had been killed by poachers for their horns.

"We have been demanding a CBI enquiry into rhino poaching for a long time. But the government is not accepting it," Datta added. ( I don't think, CBI enquiry would be useful!)

The rhinos use their horns also for behavioral functions like defending territories, protecting calves from other rhinos and predators, maternal care, digging for water and breaking branches.

I think, unable to control the poachers, the Assam Government is considering extreme measures. This is accepting its failure.

What next? Removing tail feathers to save pea cocks, tiger nails and skin to protect tigers and removing tusks from elephants to keep poachers away?

These measures are nothing but tinkering with Nature!