Is human immune system the strongest in the animal kingdom? NO!

While the human immune system is highly effective, it's not necessarily "stronger" than that of birds or other animals, rather, it's adapted to its specific ecological niche and evolutionary pressures.

Our immune system works pretty much the same way as the immune system of almost every other vertebrate. From a biological perspective, human beings are classified as animals, belonging to the kingdom Animalia, and sharing many characteristics with other animals.

All vertebrates, including humans, birds, and other animals, share fundamental immune system principles, but differ in specific mechanisms and responses.

From an evolutionary perspective, the immune systems of different species have evolved to cope with the pathogens and environmental challenges they encounter. Some animals, like ostriches, are known for having strong immune systems. The immune system is a delicate balance, and both over- or under-reactions can lead to problems.

Humans possess the most complex immune system due to its intricate network of organs, cells, and proteins that work synergistically to defend against a vast array of pathogens and maintain overall health.

Key components of our immune system:

Image source: iStock

Organs: The immune system involves various organs like the thymus, spleen, lymph nodes, and bone marrow, each playing a crucial role in immune cell development and function.

Cells: White blood cells (lymphocytes, macrophages, etc.) are the main players in the immune response, recognizing and eliminating threats.

Proteins: Antibodies, complement proteins, and other signaling molecules help coordinate the immune response and target pathogens.

Lymphatic System: This network of vessels and nodes carries immune cells and fluids throughout the body, facilitating communication and immune responses.

General Principles of Immune Systems:

Innate Immunity:All vertebrates, including humans, birds, and other animals, possess an innate immune system that provides a rapid, non-specific defense against pathogens.

Adaptive Immunity:They also have an adaptive immune system that can recognize and remember specific pathogens, allowing for faster and more effective responses upon re-exposure.

Mucosal Immunity:The mucosal immune system, which defends against pathogens entering through mucosal surfaces (like the respiratory and digestive tracts), is a key area of immune function in both humans and birds.

Complexity and Specificity:

Vast Range of Pathogens: The human immune system must be able to recognize and respond to a wide variety of pathogens, including bacteria, viruses, fungi, and parasites.

Self vs. Non-Self Discrimination: A crucial aspect of the immune system is its ability to distinguish between the body's own cells and foreign invaders, preventing autoimmune reactions.

Memory: The adaptive immune system develops a "memory" of past infections, allowing for faster and more effective responses upon subsequent encounters with the same pathogen.

Interconnectedness: The immune system is not a collection of isolated components, but rather a highly integrated network where different cells, organs, and proteins work together to mount a coordinated response.

Specific Differences and Adaptations:

Avian Immune System: Birds have a compact and less polymorphic immune system compared to mammals, with fewer receptor families. They have a single polymorphonuclear leucocyte (heterophil), but cellular thrombocytes that act as phagocytes and antigen-presenting cells. Birds have only three immunoglobulin classes (IgY, IgM, and IgA) and three T-cell receptor classes. The avian mucosal immune system has unique features. Birds, such as waterfowl, exhibit a limited inflammatory response to certain pathogens, like avian influenza, while chickens and humans can experience a strong inflammatory response.

Human Immune System: Humans have a more complex and diverse immune system compared to birds, with a wider variety of immune cells and receptors. Human immune responses are highly regulated, and breakdowns in regulation can lead to immunodepression. The human immune system is also influenced by factors like age, sex, and environmental exposures.

Other Animal Immune Systems: Other animals, like dogs, cats, and pigs, have immune systems that are similar to humans in many respects, but also have unique adaptations. For example, sharks have a remarkable antiviral defense.

Bats have exceptionally strong immune systems, allowing them to harbor a wide variety of viruses without becoming ill, due to a combination of unique innate and adaptive immune responses, including the ability to control virus propagation and limit inflammation.

Some people think animals have a stronger immune system. Because we wash our hands after using the bathroom and before we eat. But a dog will drink right out of the toilet or eat garbage it finds on the sidewalk. Vultures eat animals that have been rotting in the sun for days. The dogs and the vultures seem to be fine. This puts a strong question in their minds: Why?

Different animals adopt different strategies for their defenses (1)

Scavengers have multiple antibacterial defenses. At a basic level, these include risk-reduction behavior. For example, turkey vultures and stone crabs avoid particularly rotten carrion. Wolves avoid carrion that's been sitting in the warm summer sun. And common ravens prefer predator-killed animals to those that have died from unknown causes.

The physiological defenses scavengers have evolved are even more interesting. For example, wolves hold food in their stomachs for up to 12 hours, twice as long as humans. This gives their stomach acid longer to kill bacteria before they reach the gut. In dermestid beetles and other insects, the gut is protected by a special lining made from the antibacterial material chitin.

Surveillance is another important aspect of defense. And new molecules specializing in bacterial recognition have been discovered in the immune systems of vultures, muscid flies and black soldier flies. These molecules differ structurally from those identified in other animals and often outnumber the bacterial recognition molecules in non-scavenging animals.

New chemical defenses have been discovered in scavengers too. These are molecules of different size and structure that inhibit or kill invading bacteria. For example, blow flies produce antimicrobial peptides (AMPs), lipids and proteins that protect their outer surface and circulatory system. Also, friendly microbes in griffon vultures and common sexton beetles produce antibacterial molecules called bacteriocins and cyclic lipopeptides that protect their host's gut.

According to other scientific studies (2), these birds of prey have evolved a strong gut that helps them not get sick from feasting on rotting flesh. Researchers found that these scavengers are laden with flesh-degrading Fusobacteria and poisonous Clostridia. As bacteria decompose a dead body, they excrete toxic chemicals that make the carcass a perilous meal for most animals. But vultures often wait for decay to set in, giving them easy access to dead animals with tough skins.

Vultures will often pick at a dead animal through its back end — that is, the anus — to get at the tasty entrails. Their diet may be filled with toxic bacteria and putrid feces, but vultures are apparently immune to these deadly microbes. The results show there has been strong adaptation in vultures when it comes to dealing with the toxic bacteria they digest. The DNA of their prey was broken down in the vultures' gut bacterial samples, which suggests the birds have harsh chemical conditions in their gastrointestinal (GI) tracts, the researchers found. The acidic GI tract also filters out many microorganisms that live on decaying carrion, so the large intestines have large amounts of Clostridia and Fusobacteria.

On one hand, vultures have developed an extremely tough digestive system, which simply acts to destroy the majority of the dangerous bacteria they ingest. On the other hand, vultures also appear to have developed a tolerance toward some of the deadly bacteria — species that would kill other animals actively seem to flourish in the vulture lower intestine.

Both Clostridia and Fusobacteria appear to have adapted to the vultures' harsh gut conditions, but may also help the birds by further breaking down nutrients, according to the researchers.

While women generally exhibit stronger immune responses to infections and vaccines, they also have a higher risk of developing autoimmune diseases, while men are more susceptible to certain infectious diseases.

Women often exhibit greater humoral and cell-mediated immune responses to infections and vaccinations. This means they tend to clear pathogens faster and have better vaccine efficacy. Studies show that females have higher antibody levels and more functional antibodies compared to males. This is partly due to hormonal differences, with estrogen stimulating immune responses, while testosterone can have an immunosuppressive effect.

Research (3) suggests that the stronger immune responses in women may have evolved to protect against infections during pregnancy and childbirth. The ability to transmit antibodies to offspring through the placenta and breast milk could be a significant advantage.

So although human immune system is highly complex (the human immune system is widely considered the most complex in the animal kingdom - recent research has highlighted the critical importance of understanding immune system diversity, which is shaped by factors including genetics, epigenetics, environmental exposures, and lifestyle), we cannot say is it is the strongest in the animal kingdom. Other species, like opossums and bats, possess unique adaptations and resilience to certain pathogens and toxins and maybe better adapted to deadly pathogens than us.

Footnotes:

1. How scavengers avoid infection
2. The microbiome of New World vultures - Nature Communications
3. Sex differences in immune responses - Nature Reviews Immunology