Science, Art, Litt, Science based Art & Science Communication

No, Jamun trees cannot predict about future droughts

Q: Several people are saying Kaala Jamun (neredu) knows about the impending drought conditions and therefore produces immense amount of fruits before the drought. Is this true scientifically?

Krishna: Kaala Jamun or Syzygium cumini or Java plum, or black plum, or neredu ( in Telugu)

They look like this

Scientifically speaking, Syzygium cumini (Jamun) does not "know" about an impending drought to warn us. However, the plant does detect when it is currently experiencing water stress. The widespread belief that a heavy jamun crop foretells a drought is rooted in historical observation of plant cycles, but not in predictive meteorology.

The argument behind the belief

In folklore and agricultural tradition, it is said that an abundant jamun harvest indicates an upcoming drought. Some people explain this relationship through several principles:

Masting**: In botany, many trees exhibit a behaviour called "masting". When a plant undergoes mild-to-moderate water stress, its physiological response is to pour its energy into reproductive growth (fruiting) rather than vegetative growth (making new leaves or branches).

Water Stress: As deep taproots experience a drop in groundwater levels, the tree triggers a survival mechanism, intensely expending resources to produce seeds for the next generation.

Weather Correlation: Heavy fruiting is largely triggered by dry, hot, and sunny conditions during the flowering phase (February to March) which helps bees pollinate more effectively. The same weather conditions often precede the monsoon, linking favourable fruiting weather with subsequent dry seasons.

How Syzygium cumini handles drought

Studies show that Syzygium cumini is a remarkably hardy and drought-tolerant tree.

Adaptation: Under mild to moderate drought stress, jamun seedlings actively alter their morphology. They increase their root length and root-to-shoot ratio to pull more water from deeper soil.

Defense Mechanisms: The plant activates antioxidant enzymes (like superoxide dismutase and catalase) to cope with the stress. It also closes its stomata (tiny pores on leaves) to conserve water, which temporarily decreases photosynthesis.

This year we have severe heat waves throughout the world because of climate conditions. Even the ground water table is going down in this part of the world because of relentless urban expansion, unchecked borewell extraction, and poor natural recharge.

Rocky Terrain: Unlike cities with soft, porous soil, this region sits primarily on hard-rock aquifers. This granite geology makes natural rainwater percolation inherently difficult.

Massive Urbanization: Expanding concrete surfaces, paving over open areas, and the decline of natural water bodies prevent rainwater from seeping into the ground.

Unchecked Borewell Extraction: Heavy reliance on private borewells to meet daily residential, agricultural and commercial demands—especially during prolonged summer deficits and heatwaves—leads to extreme over-extraction.

Failed Rainwater Harvesting: Reports indicate that only a tiny fraction (under 15%) of properties actively maintain functional rainwater harvesting and recharge pits, meaning the vast majority of storm runoff is lost.

It is because of severe heat waves and dry conditions plus dropping groundwater levels to alarming rates might have put the jamun trees under severe stress and masting is the result of this.

This is not predicting impending drought conditions.

Moreover, several other plants and trees too follow the same phenomenon, this is not specific to only Jamun trees.

Scientific Consensus:

While plants are sensitive bio-indicators of their own immediate environment, they cannot look into the future or forecast long-term seasonal weather. Abundant fruiting is the plant's reaction to current or recent climate stressors, rather than a conscious, prophetic warning.

___________***************_____________

More about masting

"Suicide fruiting" (scientifically known as mast seeding, stress flowering, or distress fruiting) is a survival mechanism where trees produce an overwhelming, abnormally massive crop of fruits or seeds right before dying from severe environmental stress like drought.

While the term "suicide" in the Indian agricultural context is heavily associated with the tragic socio-economic crisis of farmer suicides, botanical suicide fruiting describes a purely ecological phenomenon. When prolonged droughts hit India's forests and orchards, threatened tree species redirect all their remaining energy into reproduction to ensure their genetic legacy survives, even if it exhausts and kills the parent plant.

The Biological Mechanism

When a tree experiences prolonged moisture and heat stress, it recognizes that its physical survival is unlikely. Instead of conserving energy for regular vegetative growth (leaves and branches), the tree undergoes a dramatic hormonal shift:

Hormonal Surge: The lack of water triggers a spike in stress hormones (like abscisic acid and ethylene), overriding the normal seasonal flowering cycles.

Resource Shunting: The tree halts the intake of nutrients for maintenance and flushes all its remaining starch and carbohydrate reserves straight into producing a massive quantity of flowers and fruits.

Fatal Exhaustion: Because the tree uses up 100% of its emergency reserves on this final crop, it completely deactivates its own self-defense systems. Once the fruit ripens, the parent tree dries up and dies from starvation and dehydration.

Affected Species in India

This phenomenon is regularly observed in both wild and cultivated tree species across India's arid, semi-arid, and drought-prone regions:

Bamboo (Mass Mast Flowering): Bamboo species across the Western Ghats and Northeast India are famous for this. After decades of growth, a severe drought will trigger a synchronized, mass flowering event across the entire forest. Millions of bamboo clumps produce seeds all at once and immediately die en masse, altering the local ecology.

Mango (Mangifera indica): During extreme summer droughts in states like Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, and Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana older or weakened mango trees sometimes exhibit an aggressive, out-of-season super-bloom. The tree becomes completely covered in fruit, but lacks the leaf canopy or water to sustain itself, leading to post-harvest mortality.

Dipterocarps (Sal and Teak Forests): Native canopy trees in Central and North India's dry deciduous forests undergo mass distress fruiting when the monsoon fails consecutively, littering the forest floor with seeds just before the parent trees perish.

Distinguishing the "Suicide Tree" of India

It is important not to confuse the biological process of suicide fruiting with India's native "Suicide Tree" (Cerbera odollam), locally known as Othalanga.

The Plant: This is a specific hardwood tree found growing natively in the coastal mangrove swamps of Kerala and southwest India.

The Name: It earned its grim nickname because its softball-sized fruits contain seeds loaded with cerberin, a powerful toxin that blocks calcium channels in the human heart, causing fatal cardiac arrest. It is historically responsible for a high number of intentional self-poisonings in rural coastal communities rather than dying from drought itself.

Mitigating Drought Stress in Orchards

To prevent valuable fruit or timber trees from entering fatal distress fruiting cycles during intense Indian summers, farmers utilize several resilience strategies:

Root Mulching: Applying a thick layer of organic mulch around the root zone helps retain soil moisture and lowers ground temperature.

Defruiting: If a drought-stressed tree begins an abnormal, excessive flowering panic-response, manually stripping away the early flowers or young fruits can save its life by forcing it to conserve its energy.

Pivoting to Hardy Varieties: Many farmers in drought-prone areas are shifting from highly sensitive fruit crops to naturally drought-tolerant species like dragon fruit, Jackfruit, Ber (Indian Jujube), Wood Apple, and Amla.

Mast seeding is the synchronous, highly variable production of massive seed crops by a population of perennial plants at irregular intervals. Scientific consensus indicates this adaptation is driven primarily by a need to saturate seed predators and enhance wind pollination, though its triggers are intimately tied to weather cues.

The Core Scientific Theories (Why Plants Mast)

Research highlights two primary evolutionary hypotheses for masting:

Predator Satiation: By producing colossal amounts of seeds in "mast years," plants overwhelm the appetites of local seed-eating insects and animals. Predators cannot consume all the seeds, leaving enough to survive and germinate. In lean years, predator populations decline due to starvation, further protecting the next massive seed crop.

Pollination Efficiency: For wind-pollinated species, producing flowers and pollen synchronously across the entire population guarantees higher rates of successful fertilization.

The Proximate Mechanisms (How Plants Mast)

How do widespread tree populations "agree" on when to drop millions of seeds? Science points to a few key biological and environmental mechanisms:

Weather Cues: Plants leverage environmental cues—such as specific regional temperature anomalies (like a hot, dry summer) in the year prior to seed maturation—to synchronize their reproductive cycles.

Resource Budgeting: Producing seeds requires immense energy. Following a mast year, plants typically experience a resource deficit and must spend multiple years rebuilding nutrient and carbohydrate reserves before they can flower heavily again.

Adult Plant Height: Recent studies have found that taller perennial plants exhibit stronger mast seeding intensity, making it a critical trait for long-lived tree species to ensure their seeds disperse effectively from elevated heights.

Ecological Impacts

Masting has a cascading effect on entire forest ecosystems. In mast years, populations of small mammals, birds, and insects spike. However, the subsequent "starvation years" lead to sudden population crashes for these same species.

No, Jamun trees cannot predict about future droughts

Replies to This Discussion

Badge

Birthdays

Birthdays Today

Birthdays Tomorrow