Science, Art, Litt, Science based Art & Science Communication
Like a geologist, a civil engineer, an architect, or a well qualified electrician.
And not a street corner vaastu pundit!
Recently one of my civil engineer friends (he has a Ph.D. in the subject) told me a builder came to him after giving him a plan and the construction work had started and half of it was completed, to change the plan to suit vaastu pundit's suggestions. When my friend told him that was not possible without compromising the building's safety, the builder was very adamant because he thought without vaastu compliance, he wouldn't be able to sell his apartments. He went and changed the plan himself. Now if an earthquake occurs, my friend told me, nobody can save the building! Even if the building is not in a geologically high risk zone, massive ground water exploitation like we are doing right now in urban areas might trigger small scale earthquakes.
Yes, balance of the building is lost if original plan made by an engineer is changed to suit vastu pundits suggestions. Some of these changes are being done, according to my friend, to old buildings too. He said, as a result, cracks are being observed in these buildings and the support systems like pillars are also getting damaged. 'People don't understand the consequences of their actions', he lamented.
And I read a very interesting news recently. We have a very severe water problem in this part of the world now. The ground water levels are going down. People are unable to find ground water even if they go very deep. In such conditions, it seems, citizens of our country are trusting science rather than Vaastu (several news paper reports confirm this!). According to Vastu Sastra, a bore well or a well has to be in the North-East direction. But when people are digging them in that direction, they are not finding any water even if they go very deep by spending lots of money. So they are taking the help of Geologists to know where they can find water and if the Geologists confirm that they can find water in South-East or South-West or North-West, people are digging their bore-wells in these corners and not in the corner what Vaastu-pundits say is the right place! Aha! Experience! Yes, it can teach you what science is and what a baseless belief is and which one is better to follow!
And these stories prompted me to write this article.
Vaastu is science, say pundits who practice it. But does it follow scientific methodology? Scientific Method progressed gradually through the processes of observation, investigation, experiment, inference and conclusion. This method gave us the most reliable means of acquiring knowledge. Vastu sastra should also be examined like any other scientific fact, applying the criterion of cause-effect relationship. Accepting Vastu sastra as science without such examination is against scientific principles. It means enjoying all the benefits made possible by science and yet denying science and scientific outlook. Such 'science' can be termed as pseudo-science!
Even if it is 'science' like some people who follow it say, it is an 'ancient one' and suited the conditions existed then. It is not based on sound science and technology of present times. And is not relevant to modern-day city constructions. I will tell you why. Vastu pundits say your main door should face East or North. Because, according to them, sunlight can enter the house directly in the morning if it faces East. But in today's tightly packed high-rise building construction, when a tall building in the East obstructs your building, don't expect any sunlight to enter your home! Similarly don't expect any air, leave alone fresh one, to enter your home when all sides of your home are surrounded by concrete devils that stop the air flow with all their might! So what a pundit says will not suit our modern times.
Whereas today's scientists like a geologist tells you about the earth zone and soil conditions so what steps you should take while laying foundations or what pillar strength needs. He also tells you where you can find maximum amount of underground water.
You should be consulting civil engineers because they tell you about safety standards, what type of building material (like concrete, glass/wood) suits your environment, what paints should be used. How ventilation and natural light can be used for energy efficiency.
Civil engineers and architects complement each other’s' work. An architect takes care of the design and shape of a building whereas a civil engineer takes care of the technical nitty-gritty like the strength of the building. Architecture is art; civil engineering is more about physics.
The primary focus of an architect remains on the aesthetic appearance of a building. Architecture is closely related to Civil Engineering, and as recently as a few decades ago, there were no architects as a separate profession at all. Architects make a building beautiful without compromising a bit its structural strength and functionality. Properly implemented concepts of architecture ensure that a building is not just strong, but that it looks good and takes care of the comfort of the inhabitants as well. A civil engineer need not bother about the looks, design, in-house lighting, greenery, and other things when an architect is around. That leaves him with the primary job of making a building stable and strong. Other than mastering the concepts of architecture, an architect is supposed to have a basic knowledge of structural engineering as well. Modern architecture sets its norms based on utility, safety, security, hygiene, durability, aesthetic & economic considerations and is completely science based..
The planning and designing of any construction project is incomplete without the input of an architect. The establishment of buildings and land with reference to functional and aesthetic requirements is a primary function of an architect. Architectural science has become a vast subject, and today we have architecture styles of different kinds. Urban architecture, rural architecture, contemporary architecture, and modern architecture are some of the styles that are studied across the globe. The inclusion of software tools like 3D Max, Maya, CAD, and CAM has made things easier for both the civil engineers and architects because graphical representation of any kind of work always adds efficiency and better understanding.
The relationship between humans and buildings has long been a special one. Our homes shelter us from inclement weather, from oppressive heat and brutal cold; office buildings provide a convenient place to gather and work. There is a dynamic kind of relationship between people and buildings. The values of architecture and modern life have diverged, but that is steadily changing for the better. Today's designers have begun along a radically different path, inspired in part by nature. This new generation of architects has a vision of buildings which do more than shelter us: they will nourish us, keep us healthy, help maintain mood, and boost productivity, all sound 'science-based strategies'. Working inside such a building will be a pleasure. The relationship between humans and buildings would, in effect, benefit from this kind of synergy, with the building taking an active interest in our well-being.
"Green", or environmentally friendly, design is the biggest buzzword right now all over the world.
Let me now discuss what important things modern science and technology takes into consideration while a building is taking the shape of your dreams.
Geology is the study of the Earth, the materials of which it is made, the structure of those materials, and the processes acting upon them. Before constructing a building it is important to know the Geology of the place so that you can build a stable structure that can last several centuries.
Many Earth processes such as landslides, earthquakes, floods and volcanic eruptions can be hazardous to people. Geologists work to understand these processes well enough to avoid building important structures where they might be damaged.
A geologist tells you about the earth zone and soil conditions so what steps you should take while laying foundations or what pillar strength needs.
Geohydrologists study properties and distribution of natural underground water reservoirs, their capacity to store water, and the movement of water through the reservoirs. More importantly, as a geohydrologist, s/he will investigate the cycles of drawing out water from the reservoirs for human consumption, as well as the replenishment by precipitation. He tells you where you can find maximum amount of underground water for your dwelling.
The first things one should be dealing with is how to conserve water ( with rain-harvesting pits), and recycling. Because without water human beings cannot exist and our water resources are getting depleted more and more as days are passing by.
An engineering geologist investigates the physical and chemical properties of rocks and soil. He can carry this information over to building houses, bridges, dams, roads, and tunnels in structurally sound areas and at minimal cost.
We all know who a Civil Engineer is. S/he deals with building construction right from the stage of planning. A civil engineer must use many different equations, applications and figures to ensure the proper procedure application. Items that civil engineers must take part in and use include chemical testing applications, drafting and design software, electrical test devices and equipment, land surveying techniques and the metric system, to name just a few pertinent items. Good analytical skills are a must for any civil engineer. Civil engineers will read and interpret many complex charts, diagrams, maps and reports available to make your construction very stable.
Civil engineering is also about maintaining and adapting the infrastructure that we depend on every day – our roads, railways and bridges; energy and water supply; waste networks and flood defences. Civil engineers have to keep this infrastructure running effectively and adapt it to meet challenges, such as population growth, climate change and natural disasters.
There are two types of civil engineering roles within the various specialisms: consultants who focus on design work and generally spend more time in the office or working with clients, and contractors who are more involved with keeping an eye on the physical construction and are usually based on-site. Both challenging environments, and all civil engineers are required to be innovative and logical individuals.
Therefore it is important to consult a civil engineer before going ahead with building a dwelling.
We should also deal with these things with the help of engineers...
Tags:
961
Engineers at the A. James Clark School of Engineering at the University of Maryland demonstrate in a new study that windows made of transparent wood could provide more even and consistent natural lighting and better energy efficiency than glass.
In a paperpublished in the peer-reviewed journalAdvanced Energy Materials, the team, headed by Liangbing Hu of UMD’sDepartment of Materials Science and Engineering and the Energy Research Centerlay out research showing that their transparent wood provides better thermal insulation and lets in nearly as much light as glass, while eliminating glare and providing uniform and consistent indoor lighting. The findings advance earlier published work on their development of transparent wood.
The transparent wood lets through just a little bit less light than glass, but a lot less heat, said Tian Li, the lead author of the new study. “It is very transparent, but still allows for a little bit of privacy because it is not completely see-through. We also learned that the channels in the wood transmit light with wavelengths around the range of the wavelengths of visible light, but that it blocks the wavelengths that carry mostly heat,” said Li.
The team’s findings were derived, in part, from tests on tiny model house with a transparent wood panel in the ceiling that the team built. The tests showed that the light was more evenly distributed around a space with a transparent wood roof than a glass roof.
The channels in the wood direct visible light straight through the material, but the cell structure that still remains bounces the light around just a little bit, a property called haze. This means the light does not shine directly into your eyes, making it more comfortable to look at. The team photographed the transparent wood’s cell structure in UMD’s Advanced Imaging and Microscopy (AIM) Lab.
Transparent wood still has all the cell structures that comprised the original piece of wood. The wood is cut against the grain, so that the channels that drew water and nutrients up from the roots lie along the shortest dimension of the window. The new transparent wood uses theses natural channels in wood to guide the sunlight through the wood.
As the sun passes over a house with glass windows, the angle at which light shines through the glass changes as the sun moves. With windows or panels made of transparent wood instead of glass, as the sun moves across the sky, the channels in the wood direct the sunlight in the same way every time.
"This means your cat would not have to get up out of its nice patch of sunlight every few minutes and move over," Li said. "The sunlight would stay in the same place. Also, the room would be more equally lighted at all times."
Working with transparent wood is similar to working with natural wood, the researchers said. However, their transparent wood is waterproof due to its polymer component. It also is much less breakable than glass because the cell structure inside resists shattering.
The research team has recently patented their process for making transparent wood. The process starts with bleaching from the wood all of the lignin, which is a component in the wood that makes it both brown and strong. The wood is then soaked in epoxy, which adds strength back in and also makes the wood clearer. The team has used tiny squares of linden wood about 2 cm x 2 cm, but the wood can be any size, the researchers said.
--
According to another civil engineer ... 'Today with advancement in civil engineering, what was not possible with those ancient vastu shastra become possible now. We need not have to depend on natural light and wind now, instead we have electricity to solve those problems. Regulations as said in ancient vastu shastra for site selection and material selection doesn't hold good now as we can stabilize any sort of soil to take load and number of options available today for building materials.
Having so much in hand today, following vastu as told by unscientific quacks is disaster. Because our society teaches us to follow many such unscientific things in the name of beliefs, we normally forget to apply our mind.
Today's vastu is totally based on directions (East, West, North and South). Now advanced vastu relates your birth sign also if you appear as rich!! To decide direction, North is the base. Again we have two North's. Magnetic and True North. If they consider either of two, their whole theory gets collapsed because both North's are not constant. True North changes from time (Uttarayana and Dakshinayana) vastu told in January will not hold good in August!! And magnetic North changes as magnetic materials in Earth change from place to place, so vastu of Bangalore doesn't holds good in Delhi or Bombay!!! Now think with common sense, how any theory holds good, if it's base is not constant!!!
To stabilize a building, if I propose 9 or 13 number of pillers, I can justify it wherever you want. But vastu Shastra forbids odd number of pillers, doors, and windows! Very pathetic.
So today's Vastu is fake and nothing but psychological exploitation'.
© 2025 Created by Dr. Krishna Kumari Challa.
Powered by