Science, Art, Litt, Science based Art & Science Communication
Q: Is there a sixth sense according to science?
Krishna: People usually recognize five senses: taste, smell, vision, hearing, and touch.
Right! If you ask a person to close his eyes and touch his right foot with his left hand, he would without seeing it, hearing it make noise, smelling it or tasting it and perhaps even without touching it before actually touching it! This sense of your own body, its position and its movement is called “proprioception.”
This sense of your own body, its position and its movement is called “proprioception.”Proprioception, otherwise known as kinesthesia, is your body's ability to sense movement, action, and location. It's present in every muscle movement you have. Without proprioception, you wouldn't be able to move without thinking about your next step. This is what we think when you ask about sixth sense.
However, Intuition, or the Sixth Sense, involves unconscious decision-making based on patterns and prior experiences, according to some people. This intuition is a cognitive process operating through thin-slicing and processing vast amounts of information from memory and pattern recognition. Intuition can guide decision-making, problem-solving, relationship assessment, and personal safety and well-being.
The brain, through a complex array of neural circuits, is something of a statistical inferencing machine.
The “highest” level of cognition, and the level possibly unique to humans, is the capacity for critical thinking using data and fact based knowledge.
The “lowest” levels of behaviour are hard-wired reflexes and adaptive “conditioned responses,” for example avoiding foods that previously made you sick.
Somewhere in between is a complex system located in the central region of the brain called the “basal ganglia” that is responsible for “habit formation”, and which is also likely responsible for what we call intuition.
Intuition means an accumulation of attitudes (including beliefs and opinions) derived from experience, both individual and cultural. It is closely associated with some prior knowledge, which forms the basis of intuition.
However, at least one type of "sixth sense" isn't real, research suggests (1). It found that what people perceive as a sixth sense may simply be their vision systems detecting changes they can't articulate.
People can sense things that they believe they cannot see such as changes in a person's appearance. But this isn't anything magical or a sixth sense; this can be explained in terms of known visual processing.
While a few scientific studies have hinted that people can sense the future just before it happens, follow-up studies concluded these results were artifacts of statistics or flawed study design.
The findings suggest the origin of the phenomenon in which a person seems to be intuitively aware of something that they don't believe they have seen or sensed in another way is due to the perception of differences in the visual metrics, not a sense that operates outside the normal laws of physics. For instance, in the case of a person who might have noticed tiny changes in somebody's appearance (such as small cuts or a bandage), but not been consciously aware that they picked up on those cues.
For those who think that they have a sixth sense, however, it's a very compelling feeling that they have a sensing ability. And you do have a sensing ability — it's just not magical, it is just plain ability that came from a normal sense without your knowledge!
Intuition — the idea that individuals can make successful decisions without deliberate analytical thought — has intrigued philosophers and scientists since at least the times of the ancient Greeks. But scientists have had trouble finding quantifiable evidence that intuition actually exists.
Some research (2) suggests that we can use unconscious information in our body or brain to help guide us through life, to enable better decisions, faster decisions, and be more confident in the decisions we make. Researchers found that people were able to make faster and more accurate decisions when they unconsciously viewed some emotional images. Essentially, people’s brains were able to process and utilize information from the images to improve their decisions. Another interesting finding in this study is that intuition improved over time, suggesting that the mechanisms of intuition can be improved with practice.
So all these studies say intuition doesn't come from no where. Prior knowledge, past experiences, through analysis of something and visual or other cues that people don't consciously notice like sounds, air currents, vibrations felt by the body, variations in light - all of these things play on our minds to predict something, which we call 'intuition'. Your subconscious mind uses a whole lot more data than your conscious mind, so things that you aren't consciously aware of can be used to make decisions, and your brain is constantly doing this. Science says intuitions get better with practice — especially with a lot of practice — because at bottom intuition is about the brain’s ability to pick up on certain recurring patterns; the more we are exposed to a particular domain of activity the more familiar we become with the relevant patterns (charts, positions of chess pieces), and the more and faster our brains generate heuristic solutions to the problem we happen to be facing within that domain.
Educated guess work? Informed imagination? Without your full knowledge? Maybe!
The word intuition comes from the Latin intuir, which appropriately means ‘knowledge from within.’
Intuition works in an associative manner: it feels effortless (even though it does use a significant amount of brain power), and it’s fast. Rational thinking, on the contrary, is analytical, requires effort, and is slow. Why, then, would we ever want to use a system that makes us work hard and doesn't deliver rapid results? Think of it this way: intuitions, contrary to much popular lore, are not infallible. Cognitive scientists treat them as quick first assessments of a given situation, as provisional hypotheses in need of further checking.
“Intuition” can be roughly understood as the brain’s ability to form probabilistic assumptions automatically, without us having much introspective insight into the process the brain is using. This is called as sixth sense by some.
Scientists don't recommend it because you need to be willing to take risks and be wrong from time to time if you go the intuition way. Critical thinking is the best option, even if you have to put in more effort.
Footnotes:
1. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0...
2. Lufityanto, G., Donkin, C., & Pearson, J. (2016). Measuring Intuition: Nonconscious Emotional Information Boosts Decision Accuracy and Confidence. Psychological Science. doi: 10.1177/0956797616629403
_______________******************________________
Updates: Some experts say there are other "sixth senses". Let us see what they are now:
Most people are familiar with the five senses (touch, sight, hearing, smell, and taste), but not everyone knows that we have an additional sense called interoception.
This is the sense of our body's internal state. It helps us feel and interpret internal signals that regulate vital functions in our body, like hunger, thirst, body temperature, and heart rate.
Although we don't take much notice of it, it's an extremely important sense as it ensures that every system in the body is working optimally.
It does this by alerting us to when our body may be out of balance – such as making us reach for a drink when we feel thirsty or telling us to take our jumper off when we're feeling too hot.
Interoception is also important for our mental health. This is because it contributes to many psychological processes - including decision making, social ability, and emotional wellbeing.
Disrupted interoception is even reported in many mental health conditions – including depression, anxiety, and eating disorders. It may also explain why many mental health conditions share similar symptoms – such as disturbed sleep or fatigue.
Despite how important interoception is to all aspects of our health, little is known about whether men and women differ in how accurately they sense their body's internal signals.
So far, studies that have investigated whether cisgender men and women (a person whose gender identity aligns with their biological sex) sense and interpret interoceptive signals from their heart, lungs, and stomach differently have found mixed results. Finding out if differences exist is important, as it may improve our understanding of differences in mental and physical health.
To get a clearer picture, we combined data from 93 studies looking at interoception in men and women. We focused on studies that looked at how people perceive heart, lung, and stomach signals across a range of different tasks.
For example, some studies had participants count their heart beats, while others asked participants to determine whether a flashing light happened when their stomach contracted, or tested if they could detect a difference in their breath while breathing into a device that makes it more difficult to do so normally.
Our analysis found that interoception does in fact differ between men and women. Women were significantly less accurate at heart-focused tasks (and to some extent lung-focused tasks) compared with men. These differences do not seem to be explained by other factors – such as how hard participants tried during the task, or physiological differences, such as body weight or blood pressure.
Though we found significant differences across heartbeat tasks, results for other tasks were less clear. This might be because only a small proportion of studies have looked at lung and stomach perception. It might be too early to tell whether men and women differ in their perception of these signals.
Our findings may be important for helping us understand why many common mental health conditions (such as anxiety and depression) are more prevalent in women than men from puberty onward.
Several theories have been proposed to explain this – such as genetics, hormones, personality, and exposure to stress or childhood adversity.
But because we know that interoception is important for wellbeing, it could be possible that differences in interoception may partly explain why more women suffer from anxiety and depression than men.
This is because difficulties with interoception can affect many areas, including emotional, social, and cognitive function, which are all known risk factors for many mental health conditions.
Knowing the differences in how men and women sense interoceptive signals may also be important for treating mental illness.
While new studies suggest improving interoception improves mental health, studies also suggest that men may use interoceptive signals – for example from their heart – more than women when processing their emotions.
Other differences have also been reported, with studies suggesting that women pay more attention to interoceptive signals than men.
This could mean that treatments that target or seek to improve interoception may work better for some people, or that different techniques may work better for others. This is something future research will need to investigate.
But while we know these differences exist, we still don't know what causes them. Researchers have a few theories, including the distinct physiological and hormonal changes most men and women experience. It may also be caused by differences in how many men and women are taught to think about their emotions or interoceptive signals, like pain.
Better understanding all the factors that affect interoceptive ability may be important for someday developing better treatments for many mental health conditions.
Authors:
Jennifer Murphy, Lecturer in Psychology, Royal Holloway University of London and Freya Prentice, PhD Candidate at Great Ormond Street Institute of Child Health, UCL.
This article is republished from THE CONVERSATION under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
____________*******************____________
Read more on this topic here: https://kkartlab.in/group/some-science/forum/topics/intuition-based...
Differences between intuition and scientific:
Intuition |
Scientific |
|
General approach |
let's try this and see how it works | let's make an assumption, implement a precise plan to study how it works, try it out, collect data, share with others, repeat the experiment (with other students who are similar to the first group) to see if the results are the same. |
Observation |
casual and uncontrolled very systematic and carefully controlled | very systematic and carefully controlled |
Reporting |
OK to be biased and subjective |
must be unbiased and objective |
Concepts |
OK to be ambiguous (general and even imprecise) all aspects of activities must be clearly defined | all aspects of activities must be clearly defined |
Instruments |
the tools used can be informal (even inaccurate and imprecise | the tools used could be informal but must be accurate and precise |
Measurement |
no real concerns about validity or reliability | It's important that measures used are both valid and reliable |
Hypotheses |
do not need to be tested or proven | very important to have a well-articulated theory or assumption that you are trying to prove or disprove |
Attitude |
no need to be critical or skeptical of results because outcomes are just assumptions | important to ask questions about the results (healthy skepticism) |
National Research Council (2002). Scientific Research in Education. National Academy Press. Washington DC., pg. 104. |
Tags:
112
You've probably been taught that humans have five senses: taste, smell, vision, hearing, and touch. However, an under-appreciated "sixth sense," called proprioception, allows us to keep track of where our body parts are in space. Alec Nickolls, a postdoctoral researcher in the Intramural Research Program at the National Institutes of Health, studies an extremely rare condition that causes the loss of this sense. His research could not only provide insights into how proprioception works, but could also potentially lead to new treatments for individuals with chronic pain.
----
But your body also has receptors for events occurring inside you, such as your beating heart, expanding lungs, gurgling stomach and many other movements that you’re completely unaware of. They’re traditionally grouped together as another sense, called ‘interoception’.
© 2024 Created by Dr. Krishna Kumari Challa. Powered by